Understanding Automated Underwriting Systems (AUS) for Mortgages in the Temecula Valley

TVMRC blog header reading “Explaining Automated Underwriting Systems” over a Temecula Valley vineyard at sunset.

If you obtained a mortgage in the 1990s, underwriting was a very different process.

When I entered the business in 1993, we were dealing with a basic credit report, income documentation, assets, debts and a lot of checks and balances. There were no FICO scores driving the process the way they do today. Underwriters looked at the entire borrower profile and used compensating factors to determine whether the borrower could reasonably repay the loan.

Today, the mortgage industry has largely moved to Automated Underwriting Systems or AUS.

What Is an AUS?

An AUS takes the information entered into the loan application—credit, income, assets, debts, liabilities, property, loan amount, down payment and other risk factors—and analyzes the overall risk profile.

The system then provides an underwriting recommendation.

It is important to understand that the AUS is not the underwriter. Fannie Mae specifically states that lenders remain responsible for confirming the accuracy of the data and making the final lending decision.  In certain aspects, the underwriter is referenced as a validator or someone who confirms the numbers used for income, assets, and credit are valid – making the AUS accurate.

DU vs. LP/LPA

There are two major systems you will hear about:

Desktop Underwriter — DU

DU is Fannie Mae’s Automated Underwriting System. It is primarily associated with Conventional loans eligible for sale to Fannie Mae.

Fannie Mae — Desktop Underwriter (DU)

Loan Prospector — LP / Loan Product Advisor — LPA

Loan Prospector was Freddie Mac’s original automated underwriting system. It evolved into Loan Product Advisor (LPA). Freddie Mac’s current Guide identifies LPA as its automated loan assessment system.

Freddie Mac — Loan Product Advisor

Both systems can evaluate credit, income, assets, liabilities and other risk factors and provide documentation and eligibility requirements.

What About FHA and VA?

FHA uses TOTAL Mortgage Scorecard, which is integrated into an AUS. FHA’s TOTAL system produces an Accept or Refer classification. An Accept generally permits processing without manual underwriting, subject to FHA requirements and any required manual downgrade. A Refer generally means the loan must go through manual underwriting.

HUD — FHA TOTAL Mortgage Scorecard

VA also permits approved AUS systems, including DU and LPA, but there is an important distinction: VA says the AUS determines a risk classification; the VA-approved underwriter still makes the credit decision.

VA — Lenders Handbook, Credit Underwriting

The Pros of AUS

There are some enormous advantages:

  1. Quickness — A complete file can receive a recommendation in seconds.
  2. Efficiency — It standardizes much of the underwriting process.
  3. Clear credit decision — Approve/Eligible, Accept, Refer, Caution and similar findings give the lender a defined direction.
  4. Less documentation — AUS findings can reduce documentation in many situations.
  5. Appraisal waivers — Certain eligible loans may receive an appraisal waiver or alternative valuation option.
  6. Looks at the entire profile — Credit, income, assets, debts and other risk factors are analyzed together.
  7. Secondary-market efficiency — Standardized AUS findings help lenders document eligibility for loans intended for sale to Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac or government-insured/guaranteed programs.
  8. Takes out the human underwriter element – Reduces impact of human error, emotion, or attitude.  Ask yourself, does the human underwriter give the same amount of balance if it the first or ninth underwrite of the day.  Or what if the underwriter gets bad news at lunch, does that sour things in the afternoon.  AUS eliminates emotions.

Freddie Mac’s LPA documentation levels, for example, can specify streamlined or standard documentation requirements.

The Cons of AUS

There are also disadvantages.

First, it can take some of the human element out of underwriting.

The old system allowed an experienced underwriter to recognize compensating factors that a computer may not fully appreciate.

Second, the software may not understand that a credit-report error is actually an error. The data must be investigated and corrected.

And perhaps the biggest issue:

AUS Is Only as Good as the Data Going Into It

If the loan officer or processor enters the wrong income, liabilities, assets, occupancy, credit information or other critical data, the AUS can produce a recommendation based on incorrect information.

Fannie Mae specifically requires lenders to confirm the accuracy of information submitted to DU and investigate contradictory or derogatory information that may not have been properly captured.

VA similarly warns that inaccurate or unverified data can invalidate an AUS risk classification.  In these cases, upfront the LO and processor need to know how to use Paychex City for tax amounts, utility-factors, and correct residual amounts.  I think this gives a high rate of false AUS Approvals or findings.

Accept/Eligible vs. Refer

This is where the AUS becomes extremely important.

An Accept/Eligible or comparable positive recommendation gives the lender a roadmap for moving forward.

A Refer or Caution recommendation may mean manual underwriting, additional documentation or that the loan does not meet the automated requirements.

And sometimes, with a properly structured file, changing legitimate variables—such as paying down debt or adding documented reserves—can change the AUS result.

The Appraisal Waiver

An AUS can also determine whether a loan is eligible for an appraisal waiver or alternative property valuation.

That can save time and money.

But just because the system offers a waiver doesn’t mean the buyer has to use it. There can be situations where obtaining an appraisal still makes sense.

Some Amazing Documentation Flexibility

This is where today’s AUS technology gets interesting.

Depending on the loan, findings can sometimes allow:

  • One paystub or limited income documentation
  • Verbal verification of employment
  • Fewer asset documents
  • Day One Certainty or direct verification of assets/income through approved data sources
  • No reserves on certain transactions
  • One year of self-employed tax returns when the applicable GSE requirements are met
  • Sometimes the bigger the down, the lesser pressure on a high fico score.  The larger the down, usually the less documentation too.

For example, Freddie Mac currently permits one year of tax returns for certain self-employed borrowers when the borrower has been self-employed in the same business for at least five years.

From Day One, AUS Helps the Transaction

From a client and loan-officer relationship standpoint, this is one of the biggest advantages.

If I can run a complete application through DU or LPA on Day One, I have a much clearer roadmap.

That helps with the preapproval, the property offer, and the documentation strategy.

And once that AUS approval is issued, it generally gives sellers and listing agents much more confidence that the buyer isn’t simply walking into a transaction with a basic prequalification.

The Bottom Line

Automated underwriting has revolutionized mortgage lending.

But it has not eliminated the need for an experienced mortgage professional.

In fact, I would argue it has made experience even more important.

Knowing how DU and LPA work, knowing what the system is looking for, understanding the findings and knowing how to properly structure a legitimate file can sometimes be the difference between an Accept/Eligible and a Refer with caution.

The computer may make the recommendation.

But somebody still has to know how to feed the computer the CORRECT information.

Picture of Tom Santos

Tom Santos

Tom Santos is a Branch Manager and Senior Loan Originator with ARBOR Financial Group (NMLS #332212, DRE #1175932), helping homebuyers and homeowners across the Temecula Valley and Inland Empire since 1993. He co-hosted Mortgage Madness Radio for more than six years and still works directly with clients from pre-approval to closing.

Schedule a Call
Share the Post:

Join Our Newsletter